How to Choose the Best Roofing Contractor

How to Choose the Best Roofing Contractor

By Contractors Booklist Editorial Team • Nov 18, 2025 • 11 min

Choosing the right roofing contractor is an important decision for any homeowner. The roof is one of the most crucial parts of your home, offering protection from the elements, insulation, and even contributing to your home's aesthetic. When it comes time to replace or repair your roof, you want to ensure you're working with a professional and trustworthy roofing contractor that will provide quality service at a fair price. In this blog, we'll walk you through the steps to choosing the best roofing contractor for your home.

1. Research Local Roofing Contractors

The first step in finding the best roofing contractor is to conduct research. You want to start by looking for roofing contractors in your local area. Local contractors are often more familiar with the climate and building codes in your region, and they are likely to have a reputation within the community. A local contractor is also more likely to be accessible for any follow-up services you may need after the project is completed.

Start by checking out roofing contractors in your area through online search engines and business directories. You can also ask for recommendations from neighbors, friends, or family who have had similar roofing work done. Personal recommendations can be incredibly helpful because they provide insight into a contractor's workmanship and customer service.

2. Check for Proper Licensing and Insurance

Before hiring any roofing contractor, it's essential to ensure that they are licensed and insured. A roofing license confirms that the contractor has met the necessary requirements to operate in your area and is qualified to perform roofing work. In many areas, roofing contractors are required by law to hold a valid license to complete roofing jobs.

In addition to a license, make sure the roofing contractor carries insurance, particularly liability and workers' compensation coverage. Liability insurance protects you in case there is damage to your property during the roofing project, while workers' compensation insurance protects you if a worker is injured while working on your roof.

Ask the contractor for proof of both their license and insurance before moving forward with the project. A reputable contractor will have no problem providing this information.

3. Look for Experience and Reputation

Experience matters when it comes to roofing. The more experience a roofing contractor has, the better equipped they are to handle various roofing issues and challenges that may arise. A contractor that has been in business for several years has likely gained valuable expertise and a track record of successful projects.

You can also look for customer reviews and ratings to get an idea of a contractor's reputation. Online platforms like Google, Yelp, and the Better Business Bureau (BBB) can offer valuable feedback from past clients. Look for contractors that consistently receive positive reviews, particularly for quality work, professionalism, and customer service.

If possible, ask the roofing contractor for a list of references or recent projects they've completed. Reputable contractors should be able to provide you with this information. A good reference can help give you peace of mind and ensure you're making the right choice.

4. Get Multiple Quotes

One of the most important steps in selecting the best roofing contractor is to get multiple quotes. While price shouldn't be the only factor in your decision, it's essential to understand the cost of the project and make sure you're getting a fair deal. Having at least three estimates from different contractors will allow you to compare pricing, services, and overall value.

Be wary of contractors that offer prices that seem too good to be true. In some cases, extremely low quotes can indicate that the contractor is using low-quality materials or cutting corners on workmanship. Conversely, don't assume that the most expensive quote is always the best option either. Sometimes, a roofing contractor may charge a premium for their services without offering additional value.

When comparing quotes, pay attention to the following:

• The materials the contractor plans to use (higher-quality materials may cost more, but they will last longer).
• The warranty offered on both labor and materials.
• Any additional services, such as cleanup or inspections.
• The timeline for completing the project.

5. Evaluate Communication and Customer Service

Good communication is vital when choosing a roofing contractor. From your initial inquiry to the completion of the project, you want a contractor that is responsive, transparent, and willing to answer any questions you may have. Pay attention to how the roofing contractor communicates with you from the very start.

Are they easy to reach by phone or email? Do they provide clear and detailed answers to your questions? Do they listen to your concerns and address them appropriately? A contractor that demonstrates excellent customer service will likely provide a positive experience throughout the entire project.

Additionally, ensure that the roofing contractor is willing to provide a written contract. The contract should outline the scope of the work, the materials to be used, the payment schedule, and the timeline for completion. A detailed, written agreement can help avoid misunderstandings and protect both parties during the project.

6. Assess the Quality of Materials

The quality of the roofing materials used is one of the most significant factors that will affect the longevity and performance of your new roof. The best roofing contractors will offer a variety of high-quality materials, such as asphalt shingles, metal roofing, slate, or tile. They should be able to guide you in selecting the best material based on your budget, preferences, and the climate in your area.

Ask the roofing contractor about the brands they use and whether they offer a warranty on the materials. Many manufacturers offer warranties on their products, which can provide you with additional peace of mind.

7. Check for Warranties

A reliable roofing contractor will offer warranties for both labor and materials. These warranties serve as a safeguard for you in case any issues arise after the project is completed. Most roofing contractors offer a limited warranty on labor, which typically covers repairs for issues related to workmanship within a specified time frame (usually one to five years).

Additionally, most roofing materials come with their own manufacturer's warranty, which can last anywhere from 20 to 50 years, depending on the material. Make sure you understand the terms of these warranties, as some may have specific maintenance requirements to remain valid.

8. Trust Your Instincts

Finally, trust your instincts when choosing a roofing contractor. If something doesn't feel right, whether it's the way a contractor communicates, the quality of their materials, or the details of their estimate, don't be afraid to move on and look for another option. The right roofing contractor should inspire confidence and make you feel comfortable throughout the entire process.

Conclusion

Choosing the best roofing contractor is a crucial decision that requires careful research and consideration. By following these steps—researching local contractors, checking licensing and insurance, looking for experience and reputation, obtaining multiple quotes, evaluating communication and customer service, assessing material quality, and checking for warranties—you can ensure that your roofing project will be completed with professionalism, quality materials, and excellent customer service.

With the right roofing contractor by your side, you'll have a roof that protects your home for years to come. Contractors Booklist simplifies the process by connecting you with pre-vetted, licensed, and insured roofing contractors in your area. We verify credentials, check insurance, and review customer feedback so you can compare contractors with confidence. Start your search today and find a roofing professional you can trust.